Having pigmented colors on your lid does not mean that you have to go all out for MAC. This look was created with the following:
Upper lid: Mary Kay Copper Beach
Lower lid: Black Radiance (Sorry I don’t know the color but I will post a pic of the quad in the future)
Eyeliner: Maybelline Unstoppable in Oynx
Mascara: Maybelline Great Lash
With the exception of the Mary Kay shadow that I’ve had for years, this look was easily achieved using drugstore brands and lasted almost all day without the use of a primer. I like to wear this when I’m going out. It tends to be a little heavy for the workplace.